9. Amadou Haidara
Club at the time - Red Bull Salzburg / Points earned - 0
Amadou Haidara broke onto the scene with Red Bull Salzburg in the 2016/17 season having joined from JMG Academy. And after spending a year on loan with FC Liefering, the Mali international did enough to prove he deserves a regular first team spot for the Austrian side.
His performances in the middle of the park ultimately caught the eye of RB Leipzig, though he struggled to match early expectations, with injuries hardly aiding his cause. Having moved to Germany in 2018, Haidara left RB Leipzig for French side Lens at the turn of the year.
However, he’s failed to earn regular game time with the Ligue 1 side, and, now 28, he’s unlikely to fully realise the potential he showed when nominated for the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year.
9. Ritsu Dōan
Club at the time - Groningen / Points earned - 0
Like Haidara, Ritsu Dōan also failed to earn a single point following his 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year nomination. Dutch side Groningen took a punt on the Japan international in 2017, and they were duly rewarded for their risk.
Dōan, after all, scored nine goals and provided three assists in his debut Eredivisie season. He followed that up with a commendable five goals and three assists to prove he was anything but a flash in the pan. A move to Dutch giants PSV Eindhoven followed in 2019, yet he struggled to nail down a starting spot.
He joined German outfit Arminia Bielefeld on loan for the 2020/21 campaign, before departing PSV for Freiburg permanently in 2022. In August 2025, Dōan secured a switch to Eintracht Frankfurt. However, after a fine debut campaign with Eintracht, he’s yet to gain any momentum in the 2026/27 season.
8. Houssem Aouar
Club at the time - Olympique Lyonnais / Points earned - 4
Houssem Aouar was already a first-team regular for Olympique Lyonnais at the time of the inaugural Men’s Young Talent of the Year in 2018. The midfielder was considered one of the most promising players on the French side’s books when he came eighth in the voting eight years ago.
The Algeria international remained at Parc OL until a 2023 switch to Italian side Roma after a high-profile move to the Premier League never quite materialised. Aouar only spent one year at the Stadio Olimpico before departing for Saudi Pro League outfit Al-Ittihad.
Aouar has been plying his trade with the Middle East giants for the best part of two-and-a-half years. Even so, there is a sense of ‘What could have been’ with the now-28-year-old.
7. Patrick Cutrone
Club at the time - AC Milan / Points earned - 5
Patrick Cutrone moved to AC Milan in 2007, arriving from Parediense, at the age of nine. And he went on to make his debut for the Serie A powerhouse in 2017, albeit as a late sub against Bologna at the tailend of the 2016/17 season.
The following campaign, the Italian did enough to warrant a more prominent spot in the AC Milan first team, and went on to score 10 goals across 28 league outings for the Rossoneri. Even so, Cutrone had done plenty to justify a 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year nomination.
In the years since, however, Cutrone has struggled to nail down a regular starting spot across spells with Wolverhampton Wanderers, Fiorentina, Valencia, Empoli, Como, Parma and, most recently, Monza.
6. Trent Alexander-Arnold
Club at the time - Liverpool / Points earned - 6
Like Aouar and Lyon, Trent Alexander-Arnold was already a first-team regular for Liverpool when he was nominated for the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year. The English full-back went on to become a Reds hero, winning the Premier League twice and the UEFA Champions League once with the Merseyside giants.
In addition, Alexander-Arnold has gone on to win 37 caps for the England national team. Having missed the FIFA World Cup, the full-back is now back in the fold and pushing to nail down a regular spot under Thomas Tuchel.
Alexander-Arnold did rattle Liverpool fans last year, however, as he admitted that he was departing Anfield for La Liga giants Real Madrid on a free transfer. The 28-year-old’s time in Spain hasn’t quite gone as planned, but he remains one of the best in his position in Europe.
4. Gianluigi Donnarumma
Club at the time - AC Milan / Points earned - 12
Cutrone wasn’t the only AC Milan representative for the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year. Compatriot and goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma also made the cut, and fared better than the striker in the voting.
Donnarumma became a mainstay in the Rossoneri starting XI early in his career, having made his debut at just 16 years of age. The towering Italian was first-choice for the Milan giants before departing for Paris Saint-Germain in 2021.
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
Gianluigi Donnarumma: "I Have No Regrets"
Italian goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma, who claimed his second Yachine Trophy in 2025, spoke in his native language about his history with PSG, his philosophy as a goalkeeper, and his new chapter at Manchester City.
During four illustrious years in France, Donnarumma won Ligue 1 four times and the UEFA Champions League once. He left for Manchester City last summer, and has been first-choice for the Cityzens ever since.
4. Rodrygo
Club at the time - Santos / Points earned - 12
There were high hopes for Rodrygo from a young age. Spanish outfit Real Madrid had already secured the Brazilian’s services from Santos before the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year ceremony took place, parting with a hefty fee to sign Rodrygo in June 2018.
Rules stipulate that Brazilian players can’t leave until they turn 18, meaning Rodryo’s Real Madrid switch was delayed until June 2019. Ultimately, it took some time for Rodrygo to begin to live up to the billing at the Bernabeu.
There was a period, however, where the Brazil international was arguably Real Madrid’s most important attacking player. Sadly, Rodrygo suffered an ACL injury in March 2026, which ruled the wide forward out of the 2026 World Cup and the opening months of the 2026/27 season.
3. Justin Kluivert
Club at the time - Roma / Points earned - 18
The son of legendary Dutch striker Patrick, attacker Justin Kluivert had a tough act to follow. Even so, the Netherlands international shone for Ajax before moving to Roma in June 2018, becoming the fifth Dutch player to represent the Italian capital outfit.
Kluivert enjoyed a fine final season with the Eredivisie side, netting 10 times and providing five assists. Yet expectations weighed heavy on his shoulders in Rome, as he struggled to live up to expectations at the Stadio Olimpico.
Kluivert went on to take in spells with RB Leipzig, Nice and Valencia across the continent before joining Premier League side Bournemouth in 2023. In the time since, the Dutchman has grown into an important player for the Cherries.
2. Christian Pulisic
Club at the time - Borussia Dortmund / Points earned - 31
Christian Pulisic broke into the Borussia Dortmund first team at a young age, and became a core player for the Bundesliga side. Injuries didn’t aid the American forward, but he showed enough promise to finish second in the running for the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year having earned 18 points.
&format=webp)
Christian Pulisic The Pioneer of the American Soccer Revolution
A leap of faith and teenage courage led a 15-year-old Christian Pulisic to Europe. There his dynamic displays helped inspire a nation.
The performances in a Dortmund shirt was enough to convince Chelsea to sign Pulisic in January 2019 as a long-term successor for Eden Hazard, who departed the Blues for Real Madrid later that same year.
Sadly, injuries continued to impact Pulisic’s consistency, and he eventually departed Chelsea for AC Milan in 2023. He made a bright start to his time in Italy but fitness problems have again proved a recurring theme for the player.
1. Kylian Mbappé
Club at the time - Paris Saint-Germain / Points earned - 110
A more-than-deserving winner of the 2018 Men’s Young Talent of the Year award, Kylian Mbappé trounced his competition for the award, earning 110 points in the process. Mbappé left Monaco for Paris Saint-Germain in 2017, initially on loan, before the move was made permanent the following year.
Mbappé was already well on his way to superstardom by the time he won the individual accolade, and he went on to win Ligue 1 six times during his seven years in Paris. In that time, the France star bagged 256 goals, which remains a record for the club.
In 2024, Mbappé departed for Real Madrid, where he has continued to pile in the goals at club level. Indeed, he scored 31 league goals in his debut season, and added 25 in his second year at the Bernabeu.
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
Why Kylian Mbappé Is Football’s Most Consistent Superstar
The Real Madrid superstar was once again a prominent presence at this year’s gala after constructing another blistering campaign for club and country.
And he came perilously close to become the first Men’s Young Talent of the Year winner to go on and land the Ballon d’Or having finished second to Harry Kane in the 2026 vote.
=9. Amadou Haidara - 0 points
=9. Ritsu Dōan - 0 points
8. Houssem Aouar - 4 points
7. Patrick Cutrone - 5 points
6. Trent Alexander Arnold - 6 points
=4. Gianluigi Donnarumma - 12 points
=4. Rodrygo - 12 points
3. Justin Kluivert - 18 points
2. Christian Pulisic - 31 points
1. Kylian Mbappé - 110 points
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)
,fit(1920:)&format=webp)